| Name | Date |
|---|---|
| Alan de St.Neots | 1238 |
| Laurence de Claire | 1246 |
| Walter | 1264 |
| Robert de Preaux or Prideaux | 1270 |
| Hugh de Valle | 1279 |
| John Eslingham probably | 1282 |
| Hughde Everton | 1305 |
| Simon de Blatherwyk | 1312 |
| Johnde Sicca Valle | 1315 |
| Robert (next known) | |
| Walter Blow or Blogh | 1349 |
| William de la More or atte More | 1361 |
| William de Talyngton | 1383 |
| William Ras or Ros | 1383 |
| Richard Bell or Beel | 1384 |
| John George | 1385 |
| Thomas Bryan | 1400 |
| Robert Gonyld de Croxton | 1418 |
| William Typper | 1444 |
| John Gymber | 1450 |
| Richard Wright | 1468 |
| Richard Wolley or Wooley | 1496 |
| Richard Oliver | 1496 |
| John Green LL.B. | 1505 |
| John Rawnds (last prior of St. Neots) | 1512 |
| Richard Palmer | 1540 |
| John Fakon | 1541 |
| ?Faucet | 1556 |
| John Tyme or Timmes | 1562 |
| Peter White | 1573 |
| William Smyth M.A. | 1583 |
| Peter White (again) | 1588 |
| Robert Dove | 1616 |
| Thomas Phage | 1622 |
| James Mabinson M.A. | 1670 |
| Samuel Taylor | 1676 |
| Thomas Shepherd M.A. | 1690 |
| William Gibbs M.A. | 1707 |
| John Hooper B.A. | 1713 |
| John Maud M.A. | 1742 |
| Robert Hudson LL.B. | 1763 |
| John Bewsher M.A. | 1796 |
| John Arthur | 1806 |
| James Appleton | 1837 |
| JohnGreen B.D. | 1848 |
| Charle Lyndhurst Vaughan M.A. | 1854 |
| Charles Hale Collier M.A. | 1865 |
| George Bowes Watson M.D. | 1866 |
| Richard Corker Meade D.D. | 1875 |
| Samuel St. Aidan Baylee M.A. | 1902 |
| Thomas Hodgson M.A. (Archdeacon of Huntingdon) | 1912 |
| Walter Knights A.K.C. | 1922 |
| Leonard Galley M.A. (Hon. Canon of Ely) | 1943 |
| Stanley Griffiths B.Sc. (Hon. Canon of Ely) | 1965 |
| Bruce Curry B.A. (Hon. Canon of Ely) | 1978 |
| Roger H.W. Arguile LL.B., M.A. (Hon. Canon of Ely) | 1995 |
| Paul D. Andrews B.Lib, Ph.D (Hon. Canon of Ely) | 2008 - 2019 |
On 1st March 2020, the Parish of St Neots was reunited with the Parish of Eynesbury to form the Parish of St Neots with Eynesbury. The Priest in Charge of the two separate parishes, who took up his post in January 2020, became the new Rector of the Team Ministry that was formed. He is:
Andrew Paul Hutchinson M.A. (Cantab), B.Th (Oxon).
Paul was previously Rector of Stokesley with Seamer in York Diocese (2009-20), Team Vicar of Penrith etc in Carlisle Diocese (2002-9), Chaplain of Sunderland University and on the staff of Sunderland Minster in Durham Diocese (1999-2002), having been ordained and served a curacy also in Durham Diocese. Before ordination, Paul worked as a solicitor in Newcastle and retains strong links with various places on and near the Great North Road and East Coast Main Line!