| Name | Date |
| Alan de St.Neots |
1238 |
| Laurence de Claire |
1246 |
| Walter |
1264 |
| Robert de Preaux or Prideaux |
1270 |
| Hugh de Valle |
1279 |
| John Eslingham probably |
1282 |
| Hughde Everton |
1305 |
| Simon de Blatherwyk |
1312 |
| Johnde Sicca Valle |
1315 |
| Robert (next known) |
|
| Walter Blow or Blogh |
1349 |
| William de la More or atte More |
1361 |
| William de Talyngton |
1383 |
| William Ras or Ros |
1383 |
| Richard Bell or Beel |
1384 |
| John George |
1385 |
| Thomas Bryan |
1400 |
| Robert Gonyld de Croxton |
1418 |
| William Typper |
1444 |
| John Gymber |
1450 |
| Richard Wright |
1468 |
| Richard Wolley or Wooley |
1496 |
| Richard Oliver |
1496 |
| John Green LL.B. |
1505 |
| John Rawnds (last prior of St. Neots) |
1512 |
| Richard Palmer |
1540 |
| John Fakon |
1541 |
| ?Faucet |
1556 |
| John Tyme or Timmes |
1562 |
| Peter White |
1573 |
| William Smyth M.A. |
1583 |
| Peter White (again) |
1588 |
| Robert Dove |
1616 |
| Thomas Phage |
1622 |
| James Mabinson M.A. |
1670 |
| Samuel Taylor |
1676 |
| Thomas Shepherd M.A. |
1690 |
| William Gibbs M.A. |
1707 |
| John Hooper B.A. |
1713 |
| John Maud M.A. |
1742 |
| Robert Hudson LL.B. |
1763 |
| John Bewsher M.A. |
1796 |
| John Arthur |
1806 |
| James Appleton |
1837 |
| JohnGreen B.D. |
1848 |
| Charle Lyndhurst Vaughan M.A. |
1854 |
| Charles Hale Collier M.A. |
1865 |
| George Bowes Watson M.D. |
1866 |
| Richard Corker Meade D.D. |
1875 |
| Samuel St. Aidan Baylee M.A. |
1902 |
| Thomas Hodgson M.A. (Archdeacon of Huntingdon) |
1912 |
| Walter Knights A.K.C. |
1922 |
| Leonard Galley M.A. (Hon. Canon of Ely) |
1943 |
| Stanley Griffiths B.Sc. (Hon. Canon of Ely) |
1965 |
| Bruce Curry B.A. |
1978 |
| Roger H.W. Arguile LL.B., M.A. (Hon. Canon of Ely) |
1995 |